What are Shareholders?

Every company has owners — but not all owners are the same.

Shareholders are the people who legally own a company through its shares or membership units. They influence decisions, share profits, and shape the business’s future.

In this guide, you’ll learn what shareholders are, the types that exist, their rights and responsibilities, and how ownership structure affects control and profit, whether in an LLC or a corporation.

What Are Shareholders?

A shareholder is anyone who owns at least one share of a company’s stock or membership interest. In simple terms, shareholders are the legal owners of the business — the people (or entities) who hold a piece of its equity.

In a corporation, ownership is divided into shares of stock.

In an LLC, it’s divided into membership units.

Regardless of structure, those shares represent both financial rights (to profits or dividends) and voting power (to influence major company decisions).

For example, Elon Musk is a shareholder in Tesla Inc., owning millions of shares that give him both control and financial upside. On a smaller scale, a solo founder who forms a startup and issues themselves 100 membership units is also its sole shareholder — just under a different legal term.

It’s important to distinguish shareholders from stakeholders.

Stakeholders can include employees, customers, or partners who are affected by the company’s performance — but only shareholders actually own part of it.

Types of Shareholders

Not all shareholders are the same. They differ by role, share class, and level of influence in the company. Understanding these distinctions is key to knowing who controls what, and who gets paid first.

1. Common Shareholders

These are the most typical type of owners. Common shareholders have voting rights that let them elect directors and approve major business decisions. However, they’re last in line to receive dividends or liquidation payouts — meaning they benefit most when the company succeeds but bear more risk if it fails.

2. Preferred Shareholders

Preferred shareholders enjoy priority in receiving dividends (and often at a fixed rate) before common shareholders. The trade-off? They usually don’t have voting rights. This structure attracts investors seeking steady returns rather than control.

3. Majority vs. Minority Shareholders

• Majority shareholders hold more than 50% of shares, giving them decisive control over the company.
• Minority shareholders own smaller stakes, so they rely on shareholder protection laws to prevent unfair treatment.

Example: In a two-founder company where one owns 60% and the other 40%, the majority owner effectively controls voting outcomes — unless protective clauses are built into the operating agreement (here's: how to write one).

4. Individual vs. Institutional Shareholders

• Individual shareholders are retail investors or founders who own shares personally.
• Institutional shareholders include venture capital firms, mutual funds, and corporations that invest large sums and often influence strategy or governance.

Comparison Table

Rights and Responsibilities of Shareholders

Owning shares gives you both privileges and accountability. Shareholders play a vital role in how a company operates, grows, and stays transparent.

Core Rights of Shareholders

1. Voting Power: Shareholders can vote on major decisions such as electing board members, approving mergers, or changing company bylaws. Their voting weight depends on the number (and class) of shares they own.
2. Dividends: When the company earns profits, shareholders may receive a share of those profits through declared dividends. However, dividends are not guaranteed and depend on board approval.
3. Access to Company Records: Shareholders have the right to inspect financial statements and corporate documents to ensure accountability.
4. Transfer of Ownership: Shares can be sold, gifted, or transferred, allowing shareholders to exit or liquidate their investment.
5. Legal Protection: Shareholders can file derivative suits if directors or officers act against the company’s interests—essentially holding management accountable.

Key Responsibilities of Shareholders

1. Follow Corporate Formalities: Respect company bylaws, shareholder agreements, and meeting protocols.
2. Pay for Purchased Shares: Ownership rights only apply once the shares are fully paid for.
3. Avoid Insider Trading: Using non-public information to buy or sell stock is illegal and heavily penalized.

Shareholders vs. Directors vs. Members

Shareholders own a company; directors run it. 

It’s one of the most common misunderstandings among new founders — ownership doesn’t automatically mean management control.

How Roles Differ

• Shareholders are the owners of the company. They invest money, hold equity, and vote on high-level matters.
• Directors are the decision-makers. Elected by shareholders, they oversee management, set strategy, and ensure compliance.
• Officers or Managers (like CEOs and CFOs) handle day-to-day operations under the direction of the board.

Corporations vs. LLCs

• In corporations, shareholders elect the board of directors, and those directors appoint officers (CEO, CFO, etc.) to run daily operations.
• In LLCs, owners are called members instead of shareholders — and they can act as both owners and managers, giving small businesses more flexibility.

Example

In small startups or single-member LLCs, one person often wears all three hats — shareholder, director, and manager. That flexibility helps early-stage founders move fast, but as the business grows, separating these roles brings more structure and protection.

How Shareholders Earn Money

Shareholders profit through dividends, share appreciation, or a business sale.  While the goal of owning shares is to grow wealth, the way that wealth is realized depends on how the company performs and distributes its profits.

1. Dividend Income

Some companies reward shareholders with dividends, regular cash or stock payouts from profits.

These are typically issued quarterly or annually and reflect the company’s financial health.

For example, Coca-Cola has consistently paid dividends for decades, making it a favorite among income-focused investors.

2. Capital Gains

When shareholders sell their shares for more than they paid, the difference is a capital gain.

This is the most common source of wealth creation for startup founders and growth investors.

For example, early shareholders in companies like Tesla or Apple earned massive gains as stock prices surged over time.

3. Share Buybacks

Some corporations repurchase their own shares from the market, reducing the number of outstanding shares.

This increases the value of remaining shares and rewards long-term holders without issuing dividends.

For example, unlike dividend-heavy companies, Amazon has rarely paid dividends. Instead, it reinvests profits for growth — and long-term shareholders have profited primarily through capital appreciation as the company’s stock value climbed over the years.

How Shares Are Issued to Shareholders

Companies issue shares during formation or later fundraising rounds.  Every share represents a piece of ownership, and how those shares are issued determines who controls the company and how profits are divided.

1. Initial Issuance (Founder Shares)

When a company is first formed, founders are typically issued initial shares that reflect their ownership split — for example, 60% to one founder and 40% to another.

These shares establish control and equity from day one and are usually documented in the company’s Articles of Incorporation or Operating Agreement.

2. Additional Shares and Investment Rounds

As the business grows, more shares may be created to attract investors or reward employees.

• New investment rounds: Issuing new shares to raise capital (e.g., Series A, B, or C).
• Employee stock options: Allocating shares through incentive programs.

Issuing new shares changes the ownership structure, so it must be carefully recorded in the company’s cap table (capitalization table).

3. Legal and Compliance Requirements

Issuing shares isn’t just paperwork, it’s a regulated process that involves:

• A valid corporate charter or Operating Agreement authorizing the issuance.
• Share certificates or digital equivalents to document ownership.
• Cap table management to track equity distribution and avoid dilution errors.

4. Why Non-U.S. Founders Need a Registered Company

Before you can issue ownership shares, you need a legally registered company recognized under U.S. law.

Without it, shares have no legal standing, and investors cannot hold enforceable ownership rights.

⚡ StartFleet helps non-U.S. founders form U.S. LLCs or corporations so they can legally issue ownership shares, onboard investors, and stay compliant — all 100% remotely, without travelling to the U.S. address or Social Security Number (SSN).

Shareholders in an LLC (vs a Corporation)

LLCs don’t technically have “shareholders” — they have members, the equivalent owners in an LLC structure.  Both represent ownership, but the way that ownership works — and is taxed — is very different.

1. LLC Membership Units vs. Corporate Shares

In a corporation, ownership is divided into shares of stock. These can be easily transferred, sold, or issued to investors.

In an LLC, ownership is divided into membership units or percentages. Each member’s interest is defined in the Operating Agreement, which outlines their share of profits and management rights.

2. Flexibility and Control

LLCs are known for their flexibility.

• Members can distribute profits in any agreed ratio — not necessarily based on ownership percentage.
• Voting rights can be customized (for example, one member may have decision authority while others are passive investors).
• Fewer formalities and annual requirements compared to corporations.

Corporations, on the other hand, must follow stricter governance rules — electing directors, issuing formal shares, and maintaining board records — but this structure is essential for raising venture capital.

3. Why Founders Choose One Over the Other

• Startups choose corporations (usually Delaware C-Corps) because VCs and angel investors prefer stock-based equity.
• Small founders and freelancers often prefer LLCs for simplicity, pass-through taxation, and easy management.

How Shareholder Structure Affects Control

Ownership percentage defines decision power and exit rights.  In every company, control flows from ownership — the more shares you hold, the more influence you have over how the business is run.

1. Majority Ownership and Control

A majority shareholder (someone owning over 50% of shares) can typically control key business decisions, such as:

• Electing or removing board members.
• Approving mergers or acquisitions.
• Setting company direction and long-term policy.

2. Minority Protections

Minority shareholders (those holding less than 50%) have limited control but aren’t powerless.

Modern shareholder agreements often include protection clauses, such as:

• Veto rights on specific decisions (like selling the company or issuing new shares).
• Tag-along rights, allowing minority owners to sell their shares on the same terms if the majority sells theirs.
• Information rights, ensuring access to company records.

Example: The 60 / 40 Split

Imagine a startup with two founders: Founder A owns 60%, Founder B owns 40%.

Even though both contribute equally, Founder A holds majority control, meaning they can make binding decisions in shareholder votes — including appointing themselves as CEO or approving new funding terms.

That’s why defining control early — and documenting it properly — prevents future conflict as the business grows.

How to Add or Remove Shareholders

Changing ownership requires legal documentation and board approval. Whether you’re bringing in a new investor or a partner is exiting, equity changes must be handled carefully to stay compliant and avoid disputes.

1. Legal Documentation

Ownership changes are formalized through stock purchase agreements (for corporations) or transfer forms (for both LLCs and corporations). These outline the price, number of shares, and terms of the transfer.

2. Update Cap Table and Corporate Records

Every change must be reflected in the company’s cap table — the official record of ownership percentages — and supporting corporate documents. This ensures transparency for all shareholders and investors.

3. Tax Implications

Share transfers may trigger tax events, especially if sold at a gain or involving cross-border ownership. Reporting these correctly helps avoid penalties and keeps financial statements clean.

4. For LLCs

Ownership changes require an amendment to the Operating Agreement.

Each new or departing member must be documented, and the percentage ownership and voting rights must be updated.

5. For Corporations

The stock ledger must be updated, and in some states, significant ownership changes require notifying the Secretary of State or filing an amendment to the Articles of Incorporation.

Common Misconceptions About Shareholders

Most founders misunderstand what shareholders actually do. 

Here are the most common myths — and the truth behind them:

• “Shareholders control daily operations.” → False. Directors and officers manage day-to-day decisions, not shareholders.
• “All shareholders get dividends.” → Only when dividends are declared by the board; not every company pays them.
• “LLCs have shareholders.” → Technically incorrect. LLCs have members, though they function similarly as owners.
• “Founders lose ownership by adding investors.” → Not necessarily; different share classes or agreements can retain control while raising capital.

Understanding these distinctions helps founders negotiate equity wisely and maintain both ownership and influence.

Final Thoughts

Shareholders are the backbone of any company — they provide capital, share in the risk, and influence its long-term direction.

Whether you’re forming a new U.S. LLC or structuring a startup with investors, understanding how shareholders (or members) work helps you protect your equity, stay compliant, and grow strategically.

Need Help Setting up your US Company?  

StartFleet helps you with your US Company formation. Apart from helping you to register a US company we offer a lot more:

• LLC and Corporation formation in Wyoming, Delaware, Florida and all other US States
• Over $500,000 perks from our partners
• US Business Bank Accounts Opening
• Expedited EIN Application
• Stripe/PayPal application consultation
• Shopify and Amazon FBA setup consultation
• Customized Website Policies for your website